Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1361-1380 of 1574

Shady Lady by the balm eyeshadow in shameless Shana

2 reviews

Works very good goes on light amazing colour and lasts for qutie a long time
COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers Eyeshadow

6 reviews

I had the COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers 3 Coordinated Eyeshadow Kit in Café Au lait and shimmering Sands . They are both cool tone neutral eyeshadows trios and like the shades, however the formula was chalky and it lacked pigmentation to point that it don't really show up on my...
NYX For Your Eyes Only Palette in Mysterious Brown Eyes

1 review

like most of nyx's products, these shadows are great. when u buy the singles, you pay $5 for each one. but in this palette you get 10 shadows for $11. they are excellent quality in terms of pigmentation and texture, etc. the colors are gorgeous and i will definetely be...
Annabelle Cosmetics Custom Quad Compact

11 reviews

The eyeshadows sold in this quad are inexpensive, and very highly pigmented. I definitely recommend these eyeshadows. I have a gold shade, and it has the perfect amount of glitter that doesn't make my eyes look tacky.
Wet n' Wild Dancing in the Clouds eyeshadow trio

1 review

This was a limited edition trio that I had been searching high and low for. I stumbled upon it while I was visiting my parents over the summer and bought 2 of them. I adore this palette! The colors are so unique and I like the combination of colors (gold, rose gold and...
Burberry Pale Barley Eye Shadow

1 review

This eyeshadow is an absolute MUST have for me (and this is coming from a person who owns quite a bit of makeup including Naked AND Naked 2 palette). This color is just about the most perfect base and I would say universally flattering on many skin tones. Its buttery soft with...
Yves Saint Laurent Vinyl Candy Eyeshadow Quad

1 review

The first time I saw this quad, I knew it had to be mine....and that's strictly based on the bright pink color! I had this quad applied by a YSL artist at the Bay and was in love after seeing the final product. It's pricey but I have noticed that I am reaching for this a lot...
Lise Watier Eye Shadow Quartet in Aquarella

3 reviews

Very nice for summer. It's a very nice color
wet n wild coloricon eyeshadow in petal pusher

2 reviews

Heard about the quality of Wet n Wild Eyeshadows online and decided to give them a try purchasing both petal pusher and blue had me at hello . I have been really impressed with the quality and pigmentation of this product and the versatility of the colour palette. I think I paid...
Annabelle Cosmetics Smoothie Eye Shadow Pencil

5 reviews

I am highly impressed with these eye shadows pencils. They are highly pigmented and they glide on easily on to my eyelids. They last all work day and the color is very build-able for intensity. I also like how these eye shadows don't' need a primer and they don't crease. I LOVE...
NYX HD Eyeshadow primer

5 reviews

Just purchased this product for the first time. And my god, I don’t know where it’s been all my life! My eyeshadow stayed put all night, even through my tearing up eyes, I for sure thought my shadow would be ruined. But it held up superbly! 10/10 reccomend everyone who wears...
Hard Candy Eye Def Metallic Eyeshadow

3 reviews

I really enjoyed this product. It is so pigmented & gorgeous :D I own 2 of them and i seriously would love some more :) They arent like some eye shadows that are all dull and you can barley see without 1000 coats . They only need a few and they pop out
BHCosmetics- 88 Color Tropical Matte Eyeshadow

2 reviews

Price is amazing, the colors are all beautiful and there's a huge variety.. however compared to other popular 88 palette brands I've tried, the color payoff wasn't the greatest. Definitely not a bad product but I've tried better. Wouldn't repurchase due to that reason.
Flirt! Limited Edition Eyeshadow Set

1 review

I got this eye shadow palette from Kohl's for around $30. The eyeshadow quality is hit or miss. Some of the colors are really vibrant and others are really difficult to see/barely last. Overall I think it was worth buying. It was fairly cheap for so many eye shadow colors. The...
Urban Decay Book of Shadows IV

2 reviews

loved this product soooo much! Everything that came in it is amazing so happy
Chanel Ombré Illuminating creme

3 reviews

This product I have fell in love with. After going from cream to cream I’m sticking with this! It’s hydrating and illuminating giving my skin that natural glowing look. My skin literally feels like silk it’s so velvety soft..highly recommend to anyone
Annabelle Cosmetics Mineral Pigment Dust

8 reviews

Ces pigment de chez Annabelle sont malade. Il n’en faut pas beaucoup pour donner une magnifique couleur sur les paupières. C’est en poudre mais pas trop poudreux.
Coastal Scents 88 Warm Makeup Palette

3 reviews

This is the perfect Neutral Palette for every beginner! It is all warm tones with so many beautiful browns, pinks, plums and corals to work with. There is a good combination of MANY matte finishes as well and shimmer and some glitter. It gives you a LOT of options to play and...
Love & Beauty eyeshadow

1 review

Hey ladies, I have finally found a half decent sparkle/shimmery eyeshadow! Being over 45 and having a hooded eyelid, I find it hard to keep my eyeshadow looking good all day. This is it...... It stays put, looks great on, and is cheap. I love a great deal especially at...
The Body Shop Eyeshadow in Pink Champagne

4 reviews

The Body Shop Eyeshadow in Pink Champagne is a great product. I have to say I love the Body Shop and the quality of there products. I love the creamy texture of The Body Shop's eye shadows and this color is just perfect for green eyes. It's a very shimmery dark pink color that...