Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1441-1460 of 1574

M.A.C Eyeshadow in Mulch

1 review

Mulch is a great crease color. The texture is so nice and it stays on long. Its probably my favourite M.A.C eyeshadow I own. So far. haha. I think its really nice for everyday wear which i look for in any product.
NARS Eye Shadow in Mekong

2 reviews

I LOVE this shade, it's so gorgeous!!!!
MAC Cosmetics Eye Shadow in Contrast

1 review

This is a cult favorite, and rightfully so! However, as awesome as this eye shadow is, I don't like the idea of paying nearly $15. Regardless, it truly is a great eye shadow that stays put all day. With primer, the color lasts all day. Without primer, it fades slightly by...
Duwop Smoke Kit

2 reviews

I also picked up this product, but in the Olive shade. I love it as soon as I swatched it in the store. A very deep olive with a beautiful pearl sheen to it. Not sparkly. These are available in some Shoppers Drug Marts which have a more varied selection of cosmetics. Mine cost...
Urban Decay Loose Pigments

2 reviews

These are almost as good as MAC pigments, but I love how they are bold colours and they don't have much fallout. Plus the packaging is super cute!
Hard Candy Meteor Eyes Eyeshadow

5 reviews

I like this eye shadow I have the colour white and I use it at the inner corners of my eye and it stays on all day, Its amazing.
MAC Cosmetics Reflects Pigments

1 review

these are nice quality, but they aren't anything special. the only thing that may make it worth the price is the outrageously gorgeous colors. but if the color is not something you're in love with, you could easily find a cheaper and just as good drugstore alternative...
Rimmel London Glam'Eyes Mono Eyeshadow

3 reviews

Here's a product that is affordable, but the quality is a little less than desirable. I've got two compacts of Rimmel London's Glam'Eyes Mono Eyeshadow - Jet Black and a shade of purple. Basically my only complaint about this item is how long it lasts. The Jet...
e.l.f. Cosmetics Beauty Book Eye Shadow

5 reviews

Most of these eyeshadows are pretty pigmented, but a couple of the shades are less pigmented, and these tend to be the matte ones. I do think a primer is necessary for this, as a couple shades are also on the powdery side, especially if you want a vibrant look. The included...
88 Coastal Scents Matte Palette

1 review

For make-up lover’s and make-up artist enthusiast this is a MUST snag loot. Coastal Scents 88 palette is totally worth buying. The product is very reasonable in price, and the good thing is the main website ship internationally so it doesn’t matter where you are. Taking a...
N.Y.C. City Duet Eye Shadow

1 review

This product packs a punch. I have tried several brands of eye shadow, looking for a really bright one, and did not expect very much from a cheaper one. This eye shadow is bold and bright! More pigment than a similar $10 product! Goes on smooth, and blends well. I absolutely...
Maybelline New York Expertwear Eye Shadow Quad in Lavender Fields

11 reviews

When I bought this product I was looking for an eyeshadow that could make my eyes look smoky like the magazines. What attracted me to the product is that it clearly tells you written into the eyeshadow what color goes in which area: Lid, Crease, Brow, Outer Corner. I thought...
stila cosmetics Eye Shadow Trio in Gold Glow

2 reviews

This is a great eyeshadow, a LOT of product, I've used it a couple times and you can't even tell at all. I like the colors, they work well togheter. If you use all three, it is a little much for everyday, but great for night. I like to use the Ivory under my eyebrows and in the...
Paul & Joe Eye Shadow

1 review

As much as I love Paul & Joe, the eye shadows and lipsticks just don't wow me. The colors are beautiful and has a slight shimmer and that's pretty much it. I find even with a primer or cream shadow base, these still crease, fade or don't show up well at all not matter how much...
NYX For Your Eyes Only Palette in Sexy Blue Eyes

2 reviews

It is very pigmented palette. It was love with a first sight and I was definitely right. I love this shades and they last all day long . It.is the right choice for a professional make up .
Maybelline Expertwear Eye Shadow Quad in Sunlit Bronze

2 reviews

This is my go to Quad, the colors vary slightly with each year, but I always gravitate towards the bronzes. The shadow itself is very pigmented, has a nice shimmer and feels velvety soft once applied. I always use an eye primer with every shadow, and with this one the shadow...
Sephora Collection Colour Diary

2 reviews

This is a great collection because of the large amount of colors to choose from. However, I did not really like the eye shadows. I thought it broke apart really easily and is really powdery. I have to agree that it is pigmented so that's a plus. I do like that it comes with...
Joe Fresh Cream Eyeshadow

4 reviews

Loved this eyeshadow as a base. Cream eyeshadows tend to crease on me and this one didn't at all. The pigmentation was good and I was super impressed with the quality for such a reasonably priced product.
Maybelline Cool Effect Cooling Shadow/Liner

4 reviews

I got this pencil in a lilac color. The color was nice but it was hard to apply it on the eyelid area. Because of this, I didn't use it that much but when I tried using it again the actual pencil part came out from the middle. I couldn't use it anymore so I threw it out. :(...
Lise Watier Eye Shadow Palette Jingle Belle

2 reviews

Every season I buy the eye shadow palette of Lise Watier. The colors are always very bright and long-lasting.