Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1461-1480 of 1574

Jane Eye Zing Mix & Match Eye Shadow

1 review

GREAT PRODUCT. GREAT PRICE. GREAT QUALITY.
Jane Iredale Eye Gloss Liquid Eye Shadow

1 review

I recently purchase the Jane Iredale eye shadow cream in light green. It's a fun method of applying eyeshadow with mineral heft. It is long-lasting and the color is great - not too green. It helps my eyes feel more moisturized as well since it's a cream rather than a...
NYX Glitter Cream Palette. Color: Ocean Breeze

1 review

Ok so I was so exited when I bought this product, just cause I love things with glitter and sparkle in it. When I went to use it I found that the glitter was only on top of the shadow, and under was just gel cream shadow, that hardly had glitter in it. I also found that it was...
Hard Candy Naturally Naughty

1 review

I was in Buffalo yesterday getting my car winterized....after I dropped it off at 8am, I thought, 'what the heck am I going to do?' The mall wasn't opening for another hour. I decided to hit a brand new (< 3 months old) Walmart. I am so glad I did...I found this...
CARGO Catwalk Palette

1 review

I absolutely love every CARGO product that I have tried so far. This palette is full of amazingly pigmented eyeshadow colours, bronzers & blushes. I have used it every day since I received it. There's lots of colours to choose from and really this palette is all I need...
COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers 3 Kit Eye Shadow - Shimmering Sands

7 reviews

This is such an amazing trio of eyeshadows - neutral, but with just a hint of shimmer that really draws attention to the eyes - it looks really good with my green eyes, and the eyeshadow quality is pretty good - doesn't crease (apply a primer). , silky feel, and goes on easily...
Revlon Molten Metal Eyeshadow

1 review

I just happened across this one day at Walgreens and had to pick it up. I was running late for work so I didn't have much time for applying my makeup. This duo made it super easy for me to do a quick eye look. The colors are so pigmented and the blending was SUPER easy...
GOSH Cosmetics Eyeshadow Primer

8 reviews

Very oily and you can find ones that are ten billion times better for half the cost.
Bourjois Paris Eye Shadow in Rose Dragee

1 review

This product is ultra soft, light and easy-to-blend formula that allows you to apply the colour as much as you want for a luminous result. Rounded, colourful and smart compact cases, as precious as jewels! A unique feminine design with integrated mirror and applicator for an...
Orglamix Mineral Eyeshadow

2 reviews

Orglamix Mineral Eyeshadow — Mineral makeup has been all the rage for the past few years. These products are said to be better for the skin because they are made with natural minerals and most are non-comedogenic so they don't clog the pores. Recently I was lucky enough...
Hot Topic Baked Eye Shadow

1 review

I bought this eyeshadow because I was attracted to the lovely purple color. This eyeshadow does not stay on unless I use an eyelid primer first. The color is great and goes on well with a brush. I really would like to try some other colors.
Bourjois Paris Eyeshadow in Marron Glacé

3 reviews

All of the colours in this line are great. They actually go on your skin the color that you see in the palette. I have had issues before with eye shadow Turning reddish on my skin but not these! A bit pricy.
Manly 120 Professional Eyeshadow Palette #1

2 reviews

I know the Coastal Scents palette is popular right now but this Manly palette is giving CS a run for their money! First of all, this product is sold exclusively through eBay but ranges from $20 to $50, depending on shipping, blah, blah, blah. I've played around with this...
Giorgio Armani Eyes to Kill Intense Eye Shadow

2 reviews

i got the shiny pink one, love it, goes well with a lot of colors. it's easy to apply and last for the whole day.its easy to remove using eye make up remover. the only drawback is the price is a bit high. but i will buy it as a treat for myself
Shu Uemura Takano Bowwow! Magic Queen Palette

1 review

The Magic Queen Palette comes with 3 pressed eyeshadows (gold/silver-gold/bonze), cream eyeshadow/eyeliner in dark green, blush (light pink w/ sparkle), and cream highlighter (pale gold). It's a beautiful palette that compliments most skin tones and the staying power of...
tarte cosmetics Ten Eye Shadow Palette

1 review

I am impressed by the generous size of the shadows, with each color in measuring roughly one inch square and deeper than what you would normally expect. They have an amazing texture that feels like satin on your lids when you're applying them. You can really tell that they have...
Smashbox Eye Shadow Quad in Bright Eyed

1 review

Probably my favorite purchase recently. This eye shadow quad gives you the perfect colors to create a gorgeous neutral smokey eye that's appropriate for work, school & everyday! At $6 this was an unbeatable deal that I had to jump on! The colors are really complementary to...
The Body Shop Shimmer Cubes

11 reviews

THE BODY SHOP SHIMMER CUBES are awful! I had high hopes, but the powder does not stay in place (ends up on your face), it doesn't last and it creases badly. If you are a contact lens wearer, they will end up shimmery by the end of the night. Very disappointed!
GOSH Cosmetics Duet Eye Shadow

6 reviews

These are really good quality eyeshadows and I got mine on sale so it wasn't too expensive!
Rimmel London Glam'Eyes Trio Eye Shadow

1 review

It is cool! I have lots! You can do makeup as professional