Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1521-1540 of 1574

Annabelle Cosmetics Mono Eyeshadow

5 reviews

I enjoy using Annabelle eyeshadow more than some of my high end eyeshadows. It goes on smoothly, blends easily with my other shadows and doesn't irritate my eyes. I wouldn't hesitate to try other shades in this line.
L'Oreal Wear Infinite Eye Shadow Single

3 reviews

I was expecting more out this eyeshadow. The staying power was minimal (though I was not using a primer.) Despite getting a rich black colour, the colour payoff was slight and required a lot of application to be noticable. It creased over the course of the day and eventually...
AVON i-mark Eye Shadow

5 reviews

I love the colors, the stay proof effect and how long it lasts. I dont like how i can feel it all day, and that you need a good remover to get rid of it.
Too Faced Glamour To Go 2 Pocket Palette

1 review

I really like this eyeshadow palette, this palette is a matte version and I really like the subtle and natural colors. Also includes 8 eyeshadows, 4 lip gloss and one blush and for the price is unbeatable. I really like the color that I could mix and match with different...
Sephora Brown Smoky Eye Tutorial Kit

1 review

I am usually picky regarding eyeshadows, but these, even if house branded, are amazing. Extra pigmented, extra blendable... just wow. I did a perfect smokey at first try. LOVE.
tarte cosmetics Flower Child Natural Eye Shadow Palette

1 review

Designed by makeup artist Tina Turnbow, this eco friendly eyeshadow palette is perfect pop of colour of spring. With 10 different eyeshadow colours, there are multiple looks (day or night) that can be created. Also included is an eye primer, double ended eyeshadow brush and...
L'Oreal Paris HIP Metallic Duo

2 reviews

Found my old one while cleaning out all my makeup. They have a lot of fallout and just are kind of powdery
N.Y.C. New York Color Metro Quartet Eyeshadow

2 reviews

Great shades and with the right primer last all day :) I adore this!
Annabelle Cosmetics Studio Pigment

2 reviews

There are great loose powder pigments. I have a bunch of em but LOL was the color in front of me. It is a bright yellow, when applies loose as a shadow it's beautiful. Nice bright cheery color with good even color, and a hint of shimmer. What I really love about these...
e.l.f. Cosmetics Eye Transformer Eye Shadow

2 reviews

Target woman beware! I went to target when i was told by elf that there products were on sale, what i sale ugh i didnt know 4 dollars for there normal dollar products was a steal honestly there eye transformer is average it would have been better had the price been lower in...
COVERGIRL Purple Eyeshadow Quad

6 reviews

Love this eye shadow goes on well heheh love that it don't flake or crease or crackmkn my eyes ,makes my Blue eyes really stand out.I got it as a gift for my birthday
Annabelle Cosmetics Galaxy Eye Shadow Palette

3 reviews

I've had this palette for sometime. I'm not certain if it's a regular item or if it was a seasonal offering but I pull it out in the fall as it has nice brown, gold and reddish shadows that work well in the fall. the quality is as good as when I bought it and the shadows...
Rimmel London Color Rush Trio Eyeshadow

7 reviews

Rimmel London Color Rush Trio Eyeshadow is very pigmented and the shades are pretty. The colours are easy to apply with your finger or with an applicator. The eyeshadow lasts all day and cleans off easily with cleanser and water.
Sigma Makeup Beauty On The Go Kit in Neutral Shades

1 review

These eyeshadow palettes are such a steal for what you get. Instead of getting a palette with four eyeshadow already in it, you get a compact case with a huge mirror (woot!), and 4 individual eyeshadow that includes a tiny applicator and mirror. To use these palettes, you simply...
Jesse's Girl Loose Eyeshadows

6 reviews

Can you say new highlighter? YAASSS QUEEN!
The Body Shop Eye Shadow

10 reviews

I love feeling like a million bucks with this shadow I feel unstoppable and wow to feel pretty is so nice I really love the color and the product doesn't make my eyes itchy
stila cosmetics Eye Shadow Trio in Mazatlan

1 review

This lovely product from Stila has been so handy to have around because it's trio. And not the puny little trios you see from other brands like Smashbox (sorry smashbox, you know I love you), it's a large compact size! Aside from the quantity, the colors are just so...
Rimmel London Stir It Up Cream Eyeshadow

10 reviews

I really liked it this eyeshadow creme because it really blended smoothly and it was nice to have something with a different type of texture. I loved the pigment and it was great because it didn’t rub off
GOSH Cosmetics Quattro Eye Shadow

3 reviews

Gosh is now my go to make up. I love the quattro eyeshadow. The colours are beautiful and blend together beautifully. I can create a gorgeous smoke look that you would think was done professionally. The colour lasts all day and stays vivid. Try it you won't regret it.
COVERGIRL Eye Enhancers in Swiss Chocolate

4 reviews

I was really happy with this eye shadow,loved the color, it went on smoothly, stayed on for hours,very impressed,love cover girl products