Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
1541-1560 of 1574

Urban Decay Sustainable Shadow Box

1 review

This palette is a nice one, i wouldn't say it is my favorite but urban decay is a wonderful brand. It's very pigmented and very fun to play with. My only down fall about it is all the sparkle in it, as you put it on your eyelids a whole bunch of the sparkle fall out...
Forever 21 Shine Eye Shadow Palette

1 review

The colors looked pretty in the package and I thought it was a great price so I bought it. It was horrible. The eyeshadow fell all over my face when I trying to apply it. Do not buy it. I will go back to my Dior eye shadow. I guess you pay for what you get.
Inglot Single Eyeshadows

1 review

I used to be a Senior makeup artist with the company before they closed their Toronto stores :( They are still available in Montreal and other areas across the globe though :) (not yet available online). THEIR PRODUCTS ARE AMAZING!!! Better than any other eyeshadow I have ever...
Maybelline Expertwear Eye Shadow Duo - Rose Tints

2 reviews

I have this product in 133 coral lily. (The colours are actually much lighter than they appear in the photo!) The apriocot colour goes on smoothly and it shows with one to 2 applications. The lighter colour takes more coats but it acts as a great eyebrow highlighter. I...
Everyday Minerals Eyeshadow in Cliche

1 review

A nice base eyeshadow for an everyday metallic sheen to the eyes. It is a light grey/silver colour. Don't let that frighten you though, it is actually very light and not over the top at all. I like applying it as a base and then lining my top lip with pencil eyeliner...
Mac Cosmetics Eye Shadow in Odd Couple

9 reviews

Did not last long enough, too sparkly. People rather buy their regular eyeshadows
Cargo Hands of Hope Eye Shadow Palette

1 review

I received this product to review from Cargo Cosmetics. I haven't been a big eye shadow user for several years, but this palette may just be the product to convert me back to the beauty junkie that I was in high school! I have only used about half of the colours so far...
Sephora Color Play Palette

2 reviews

Tres Bon rapport qualité prix, je Le recommande à tous. Ils y a du choix Et Le Produit tient bien.
Rimmel London Color Rush Mono Eyeshadow

7 reviews

It's a decent eye shadow. I like shades they offer and this one works well for me. Doesnt last too long though.
Lise Watier Sea Belle Eye Shadow Quartet in Lagoon

3 reviews

Fard à paupières de texture fine et légère qui s'applique avec douceur pour un fini translucide ou opaque selon l'effet désiré.je le recommande a tous mes amis ,,,
Josie Maran Eye Shadow

1 review

I tried the Rio de Rose Gold after reading rave reviews. Found it to be too orangey/bronzey for my liking. A little goes a long way, so layer in a bit at a time or you'll be stuck with a garish splash of colour that can be hard to remove. I also find the company's claim that...
Eye Enhancers 3-Kit Shadows in Firecracker

4 reviews

This is long lasting and I had gotten slot of compliments with this eyeshadow. You can use separately or together for a more dramatic look this is a great product
Smashbox Muse Artist's Palette

1 review

I got this pallete as part of the birthday gifts. I've always been more into the vibrant, bold and strong colours for eyeshadows, so this was a drastic change for me. The colours are not as pastle-ish as the picture shows. In fact, there's more shimmer than I had...
Rimmel London Stir it Up in Wassup

1 review

Girly Girls, how can you pass up something shiney with glitters? I couldn't! I love make-up so I went out and bought this to try it and review it. It is not office wear. More an evening out. Great for creating dramatic eyes but you can play it down. Make-up wears well on me...
Annabelle Cosmetics Trio Eyeshadow

5 reviews

The Haute Chocolate Trio is my go-to everyday shadow palette. I just wish it had a bit more longevity, but otherwise I love it!
COVERGIRL Eyeslicks

5 reviews

I really liked the Cover Girl eyeslicks. Easy to apply even when you are in a morning rush. It lasts all day for me and a good test was in the heat. I didn't find that it smeared or ran like others I have tried. I would recommend adding it to your makeup stash!
CARGO Eyeshadow Palette in Toronto

2 reviews

Received this as a gift for Christmas and I love it! The colours are very nice and pigmented, not too much fallout :) haven’t done much research on the brand but I seen that they are cruelty free which is very important to me!
Maybelline Roller Color Loose Powder Eye Shadow

2 reviews

This was stupid. The roller was very awkward to use and control and it didn't distribute the powder evenly. So you then you need to go in with a brush and get the look you want. So you might as well just skip the roller and use a eyeshadow that goes on with a brush. Plus...
L.A. Girl Eyeshadow Quad

1 review

I purchased the L.A. Girl eyeshadow quad in the blue-gray tones and was excited to use it because the colors looked very pretty just by looking at them. I appreciated the low price at first, since it did come with four eyeshadows to work with and their sizes are pretty average...
QUO Mineral Matters Eye Duo

3 reviews

I love Quo make up! I recently tried this "Duo" eye shadow at a friend's house.. She's practicing to become a make up artist, so she happened to use this on me. I absolutely loved the outcome! The look was fabulous, and was subtle but bold.. a nice combination. There was a nice...