Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
181-200 of 1574

QUO eyeshadow Vanilla

1 review

I have tried many high end Matte eyeshadows. I came across the Quo Matte Vanilla single eyeshadow. The texture is like butter silk with great coverage. I wanted a grey, blue and purple colour so I had to purchase a few quads. I wish the grey, blue and purple would come in a...
ALMAY VELVET FOIL CREAM SHADOW in CUPID GLAZE

2 reviews

I purchased this product to serve as my everyday to-go eyeshadow and this works perfectly! It lasts all day with no fallout, and I love how easy it is to apply .A little does go a long way so truly economical in my mind. And after a recent ten hour day at work--still no creasing...
NUDESTIX Magnetic Eyeshadow all Shades

2 reviews

I love love this product. There is a good range of colours to choose from. I love that it is long wear and easy to apply. They are super easy to take on the go and are very convenient. You can use with your fingers or even blend with a brush. I often use these on my makeup...
Juvian Place The Saharan Eyeshadow Palette

1 review

@juviasplace As many have requested, this is the close up of the palette. The pigmentation is out of this world 🌍. I did find some color isn’t exactly same as true to color on the eyes 👀. Keep in mind, I spend $20 USD and the minor flaw. It is still a steal in my books...
Storybook cosmetics palette fairytale

3 reviews

This pallet was just ok. Wasn’t a fan of all the shades, I only use 3 of the shades but the ones I did use are good. Pigment was nice and it blends nice.
NYX Ultimate Shadow Palette

16 reviews

This palette is alright, I love how compact it is and travel friendly. It's easy to store and you can bring it on trips. The shade variety is okay, I would have preferred a good mix of mattes and shimmers. Also, some shades are too similar so some dark blue shimmers would have...
NYX Toronto Lip,Eye,face collection

1 review

This Collection from NYX is amazing a beautiful grey lip, the blush and highlighter can be used on the eyes, the vivid pink and grey shadows blend nicely with little to no fall out.
HELIOS BEAUTY EYE SHADOW

2 reviews

I received this eyeshadow through ipsy and I use it quite often. The pigment is strong which helps it last longer. For extra pigment I often wet my brush beforehand!
Coastal Scents 88 Piece Makeup Palette

54 reviews

I remember getting this eye shadow palette for Christmas 1 year. I believe I still have it. The pigmentation is there but the size of the pans erk my nerves. If they pans were bigger than I wouldn't complain. It's great for a beginner though.
too faced crystal whips

1 review

I love this product because the quality is amazing, it lasts for hours on my lids, travel friendly and shade range is beautiful. Every time i use the too faced crystal whips i get so many compliments as it makes your eye makeup look beautiful and makes it look like you put a lot...
Essence 16 Pan Eyeshadow Palettes

5 reviews

This palette is very pigmented and it's affordable. It's easy to use and blend in good. It feels smooth and amazing. This palette is colorful and makes my eyeshadows pop out.
Raining Men Top Ten Eyeshadow Collection

1 review

I bought the Hard Candy 10 shadow palette from walmart in 2009 for under $10. There are quite a variety of colors. They are all fairly dark. It came with a sponge applicator that needs to be replaced after a few uses. It has a mirror in the compact. Overall I have not used it...
Space Case Cosmetics Eye Shadow - Messy Lochnessy

2 reviews

This shadow knocks it out of the park for me. Not only is this colour grungy and beautiful but the quality is great. Fine milled and buttery this shadow applies easily with a brush or finger and gives a gorgeous look either way Space Case is 👌 I keep buying more and more...
Melt Cosmetics Smoke Sessions

3 reviews

I love the soft smooth feel of this product on my lids. The matte colours are darker than they appear and are very good for smokey eyes or liners. The glitters are thick, creamy, and fantastic! Due to the creamy nature the colours do tend to travel, so use a primer and all is...
lancome Color Design Sensational Effects Eyeshadow Smooth hold

1 review

These eye shadows are great, I am in love with them. The application is so smooth and it does not settle into the cracks of my eyelids (this is a huge eye shadow pet peeve of mine). This shadow is available in so many different individual colors (also available in set), I am...
Tarte Grav3yardgirl Swamp Queen Palette

22 reviews

This is actually my favourite go to pallet for simple daily looks. I keep it at work with me for last minute touch ups. And it’s a bonus it has a blush, bronzer and highlight. The colours are beautiful and neutral with a little shimmer. And it smells amazing. Great for a...
SHANY eyeshadow palette, Boutique, 40 colour

1 review

So many fun colours to choose and blend. Lots of variety, so no need to use different palettes. Very vibrant and eye catching. Received many compliments, as well!
Rimmel London Magnif'eyes Shadow Eye contouring palette

19 reviews

i purchased the Rimmel Magnif'Eyee Contouring Palette in the colour electric violet. This palette comes with three matte shades and the other nine colours are all shimmery. There is not one colour in the palette that I have not used. All the colours compliment each other...
L'Oréal Paris Paradise Enchanted

1 review

Hands down one of my favorites!. I wasnt expecting it to be that great but definitely worth the money. And it's also scented eyeshadow, which I have never used befour but smells amazing. I am one that hates pinks but these are amazing shades.
Elizabeth Arden Eye Shadow Duo Classic Khaki #01

1 review

@ElizabethArden Eye Shadow Duo Classic Khaki #01 is my very favorite eye shadow palette I have tried in a long time. It is formulated with Vitamin A derivative so I found it does not crease, smudge and it even helps my fine lines not to show as much. It also supports my skin’s...