Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
301-320 of 1574

THEBALM COSMETICS Foiled Again Eyeshadow in Locked Up

2 reviews

I received this eyeshadow in one of my monthly beauty subscription boxes. It's a pretty shade but wish it was a bit darker. I haven't tried applying it wet yet.
C.Y.O Cosmetics Crush On Metal Eyeshadow

2 reviews

The pigmentation of this product is amazing it really makes your eyes pop. The shadow lasts all day and does not crease. This product is a must buy for make up fans.
Naked Eyeshadow Palette (Brown)

9 reviews

The colours in this pallet are absolutely ugly and would never buy again. They also don’t blend it all so your make up looks like a two-year-old did it. Do not buy and would never recommend
Elf Endless Eyes 100 Color Eyeshadow Palette

1 review

This eyeshadow palette is great when you want to save money and refrain from buying expensive, high-end eyeshadows for a while without sacrificing too much quality. With 100 eyeshadows to choose from, there's plenty of options from just everyday looks to nights out on the town...
BH Cosmetics Eyelights Liquid Eyeshadow

1 review

If you’re looking to turn up the volume on your glam, the ultra long-wearing formula of Eyelights waterproof eyeshadows will have you glimmering all night. Six mesmerising holographic shades of Eyelights are available, and these can be worn alone or as toppers for your regular...
Revlon photoready primer, shadow + sparkle

2 reviews

I really love these colours . I always tend to do different makeup . I feel i can trust this eye shadow because they go on smooth . One advice is really if you want this to last all day is to wear eye primer for your shadow . This is how it makes this last all day .
ColourPop Supernova Shadow

2 reviews

Excellent! Got this from a friend so I am not sure about the price. I am not that great with sparkling shadows since they don't blend as well for me, but even an amateur like me pulled it off so I am sure it is a fantastic shadow. It goes on very easily.
smith & cult eye book of eyes quad collection

1 review

Smith and Cult products have a very unique design appearing somewhat dented. I’m still not sure whether I like this or not, but they definitely stand out. The outside gets marked very easily with fingerprints and dust and is hard to clean though. The compact is large for...
Wet n Wild coloricon eyeshadow quad

1 review

When looking for a particular shade of eyeshadow, I happened upon this one with pinkish tones I like to use to accent my eye color. It has 4 shades so you can create different looks!!! I chose the Petalette
Chocolate bar palette by Two Faced

8 reviews

Great product and colors are great colors stay on a long time Great for everyday wearing nights out..................................................
NYX Cosmetics Love Contours All Eye and Face Palette

10 reviews

I got this as a Christmas gift, so I’m not sure of the value but I know Nyx is usually not too expensive. The highlighters are beautiful 😍 the eyeshadows are great for creating many different looks and have a great amount of color along with blending really well. My skin is...
L'Oréal Paris Infallible Paints Eyeshadow - 310 Army Camo

3 reviews

Blend, blend, blend. Then wait, and set, and enjoy bold vibrant color ALL day, all night, however long you like. Once set, it doesn't budge, doesn't smear, doesn't fade,and definitely doesn't disappoint.
Melt Cosmetics Love Sick Stack

1 review

This is my absolute favorite stack from Melt Cosmetics! The colors go so well together, and I can create so many beautiful looks with this stack. I love making sunset type looks with these highly pigmented, easily blend-able colors! Amelie is my favorite!
tarte tarteist pro palette

10 reviews

I love this palette. It has a lot of different shades in it. The colours are nice and they aren’t chalky. I find they blend very wel on the eye and wear for a long time. I recommend this palette
Soiree Diaries Eyeshadow Palette By Pur The Complexion Authority

5 reviews

I love the colours that come in this sweet little palette. There are a variety of matte colours as well as shimmers so it's a palette that is easily buildable and works well with other palettes/colours. Although the colours are quite simplistic they blend quite easily. I think...
Wet 'N Wild  Icon eyeshadow trio

3 reviews

This eye shadow trio should not be overlooked. It is pigmented and stays on all day. There is not one bit of fallout with this product. It applies nicely and the colours are easily blend able. The one thing I would say is that the brush it comes with it kind of crappy, so use...
Morphe 35 T palette

3 reviews

I really liked this product, I definitely purchase this again. It stays longer and looks amazing. Love this
Lime Crime Venus II Palette

3 reviews

Nice travel friendly palette. The packaging is very sturdy and comes with both matte and shimmery colours to make a complete eye look. I wish it came with a small brush to make it better for travelling. My favourite shade is the mustard yellow shade which is unique to my eye...
Avon True Color Multi-Finish Eyeshadow Quad

1 review

I own 2 of the these and will for sure buy some more in the future. I love using them for traveling, on the go or when i need a quick eye look. It already comes set with a whole eye look : including 2 dark colours, a matte crease one and a shimmer outer corner as well as a lid...
Orca gold rush eyeshadow

1 review

Super pigmented eyeshadow, it is metallic. I love using it by itself or with other colours to create a great look. Lots of product for the price. I would definitely purchase again as it lasts a long time