Eye Shadow Reviews

There is no better way to experiment with your beauty look than with eye shadows.  Use the same palettes to start with a demure daytime look, then swipe on extra pigment for a dramatic evening transformation.  Smokey shades, neon brights, and classic taupes create a million beauty personalities for the one and only you.

ChickAdvisor members love upscale brands like MAC, Avon Mark I-Mark, and Stila; favourite mainstream brands include Maybelline New York Eye Studio, L'Oreal Paris HiP (High Intensity Pigments), and Coastal Scents.

For ultimate staying power, don't forget an eye shadow primer like Urban Decay Primer Potion or Too Faced Shadow Insurance!

Sort by:  DateRating
321-340 of 1574

Doucce Freematic Eyeshadow

8 reviews

Ok so I loved my mini sample from my Ipsy bag so much I stretched it out to last me a year and a half. So I finally bought a full freematic palette and I'm in love with it , Lasts all day and has amazing pigment. If you have never tried it i recommend it. I ordered it and it...
Skinny Palette Annabelle

1 review

WHY YOU'LL LOVE IT This eyeshadow palette has a smooth and silky texture that glides on effortlessly, giving you intense colour with ultra-blendable pigments. Benefits • Intense colours with ultra-blendable pigments • Smooth and silky texture that glides on effortlessly •...
ITTSĒ Matte Eyeshadow in Changing to Flats

1 review

This eyeshadow is gorgeous. It is nicely pigmented and shows up bold on my skin. The deep plum colour is beautiful and blends well. So soft on my lids. Can also use smaller amounts for gorgeous sheer looks.
smashbox Photo Edit Eye Shadow

2 reviews

This little wonder is the perfect on the go day to day shadow story. Blends like a dreams and is super pigmented but not to the point of being too dusty. Easy and great
e.l.f eyeshadow pallette

3 reviews

The colours are great and at first I loved it. After a few hours, the shadow faded in spots so that I had to reapply it s few times. I'm disappointed as I love the colours. Don't waste your money
OFRA Cosmetics Eyeshadow in Millennium Gold

2 reviews

I got this in one of my monthly subscription boxes. I don't mind the shade but would like to have tried a different one, something that actually shows up.
Marc Jacobs Eye-Conic Multi-Finish Eyeshadow Palettes

5 reviews

This is such a beautiful palette by Marc Jacobs (it's the fantastic palette). His formula is unbeatable. I have hazel eyes and this palettes color story compliments them perfectly. I bought this palette for 12$ US off of boxycharm, a deal you can't beat. His palettes run for...
NYX In Your Element Palettes

3 reviews

Metal element palette from NYX hands down is my favourite. Loving the opulent looking chrome shimmers and the buttery smooth powder formula that is highly pigmented and long wearing. Like gift wrap but for your eyelids!
Burt's Bees Eye Shadow Trio

2 reviews

I quite like the trio, though in the palette I got, one color is waaay too dark for me so I am using the other two more. Nothing wrong with that, that happens. I would like if the eyeshadow stayed on a bit longer than it actually does but I don't really use eye shadow primer so...
Mac Cosmetics Pro Pigment Powder Eye Shadow

42 reviews

I got this mini mac pigment about 2 years ago. It was my first purchase from mac and I didn't really know what to expect. I got it in the shade blue brown and all I have to say is WOW. It's such a unique shade. It lasts all day. So beautiful and the mini lasts a long...
MAC Eyeshadow Tilt

1 review

I have had this color in my MAC collection since high school. Its a beautiful very pigmented frosty blue that isn't too bright and is also quite blend-able. It always has gone on very smoothly and is very true to the color that you see in the pan. I love wearing it if I'm...
Elizabeth Mott Shimmer Eyeshadow Single in Mermaid Teal

2 reviews

I received this in an Ipsy box and holy guacamole it is crazy gorgeous!! I I received a stunning mermaid-y green color that is so pretty but unfortunately, it’s not something I wear often. However, the pigment, the payoff, the formula is fantastic so I would definitely...
Almay pure gold baby eyeshadow

2 reviews

I like this eyeshadow. Adds a great warm glow to any color palette. Is also great on its own. Convenient package tp take with you on the go. I recommend
Lime Crime Venus Palette

4 reviews

I bought this palette because I liked the shades and the packaging, but when I actually used it, I loved the formula! It is very pigmented, soft and blendable. A bit on the expensive side though.
Nars Dual-Intensity Eyeshadow

1 review

these shadows are very pigmented and vibrant and there is very minimal fallout, if any. I also love that these shadows can be applied to the lids wet to create an even more intense look. The shadows apply very buttery and I was really impressed with them. I highly recommend...
L'Oreal Paris LA Palette Nude Intense

2 reviews

I found La Palette very pigmented which is great but a bit too powdery which is not that big of a deal. It was long lasting and the colours are perfect for that natural or dramatic look. I loved the packaging very welcoming and intriguing. I found it very nice and would...
NYX Cosmic Metals eyeshadow

5 reviews

My only metallic eyeshadow pallet, it is small but they are great quality and I definitely recommend for anyone looking to try out metallics. It comes with six different colors and I was very pleased when I got it.
Avon True Color Matte Eyeshadow Quad

1 review

I loving using these with other palettes. They come with great matte colours that can be very similar or 4 different but complementary colours. They have really good pigmentation and texture but nothing to fancy. The price is incredible especially since i can get them on sale...
Make-Up Revolution Pro HD Amplified Palette: Smoulder

2 reviews

Jai vraiment aimé cette palettes de couleur la pigmentation est vraiment très belle et elle reste très longtemps!! Elle ne s'efface pas apres quelques heures
Nyx Prismatic Shadow

8 reviews

I own a lot of eyeshadow palettes. I mean over 60 to say the least so when I purchase an eyeshadow single, it has to be something like nothing I own. These eyeshadows from NYX are amazing. They're pigmented and they don't budge. My favourite is the shade girl talk, it's an icy...