Eyeliner Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
221-240 of 906

Rimmel London Scandal'Eyes Waterproof Eyeliner

31 reviews

This has been my favorite eyeliner for years. It's not hard to out on, comes off fairly easy when you wash your face. It doesn't smudge much during the day and doesn't bother my eyes like other eyeliners have
essence Liquid Waterproof Eye Liner

29 reviews

This has got to be some of the best liquid eyeliner that I have ever used. Not only does this stuff stay on in the shower - bath and pool but this stuff stays on when you go to bed at night. This truly doesn't come off unless you use waterproof eye makeup remover. This even...
Kajal Extreme Intense Eyeliner Pencil

1 review

I bought this eyeliner a while ago - Navy blue colour, and I really liked the eyeliner. IT is very smooth to put on and the colour itself is gorgeous. It can be worn with blue colour or with party wear clothes, and would look amazing at parties. I would highly recommend this!...
Colourpop Créme Gel eyeliner pencil

1 review

The formula is good, very smooth and pigmented! It is soft and easy to apply but it breaks easily and after three or four hours it transferred below my eye and it didn't seem true black to me more it was more like a dark gray. It is good but I've used better drugstore eyeliners.
Butter London Stroke of WOW Roll On Precision Liner

1 review

I was excited to find out I was receiving this in a monthly makeup subscription box a few months ago. I have difficulties applying my liner perfectly with the same angle/thickness to each eye and this nifty tool was going to make that easier, or so I thought. The liquid is...
Cover girl intensify me eyeliner

18 reviews

These types of eyeliners can range in price but this CoverGirl one is of great quality. It offers two types of liner for a thicker or thinner look. I don't wear this everyday but definitely enjoy for an evening out. It's easy to use and very reasonably priced.
Jonteblu eye liner

4 reviews

I received this in my ipsy bag and I love it. It's a nice black. It glides nicely. It lasts all day- even longer. I would recommend this product to anyone.
Trish McEvoy lash enhancing liquid liner pen

1 review

I really love how this liquid eye liner pen works so nice. I dont use it ever time i put on makeup. But I use it days I wear my contacts. It is black and gives me the bold look. You can use the thin look or lay the pen sideways more and the line be thicker according. It is a bit...
Mostory Smudge-proof Winged Eyeliner Stamp

1 review

This was the worst eyeliner I've ever tried to use. The pen dried up after 2 uses, and it felt like I was using a sharpie. It dried down somewhat tacky and made my lids feel heavy. Do not buy!!
Cover girl liquid eyeliner

1 review

Cover girl liquid eyeliner is amazing! I always had problems finding eye liner that I could use. They always seemed to bother my eyes some how. Whether it was making them itchy, or red, or simply just wearing off very quickly. But cover girl liquid eye liner doesn’t bother my...
NYX artistry liner

1 review

I bought 2 of NYX artistry liners one is super edgy and the other is the put a wing on it the edgy one is almost like the size of a highlighter it’s good for filling ina bigger space where the put a wing on it is thinner like a marker for more precise lines they also have 2...
Vintage Smokey eyeliner

1 review

This Smokey liner is my new favourite of the type. I was devoted to another brands Smokey liner for years. Not anymore! This liner glides on super smooth, with no tugging or pulling. It is highly pigmented, and smudges, and blends for the perfect Smokey effect. It stays put all...
Savvy Minerals by Young Living

1 review

I've been using pencil eyeliners all my life because I found other eyeliners sucked..... until I came across SAVVY MINERALS by Young Living. It's so light and airy, it's clean, natural minerals, no chemicals, toxins, Parabins, fragrances, etc. It goes on really smooth! Stays on...
Lise Watier waterproof eyeliner blue noir

1 review

I wear eyeliner everyday and I was so thrilled to come across this. It's natural looking, doesn't smudge and is easy to remove. I can't live without it!
TARTE COSMETICS Sex Kitten Eyeliner

4 reviews

This is my favorite eyeliner. It came in Tarte's limited edition Treasure Box set as a full size and I'm in love!! It feels creamy so it's easy to apply without having to drag it across my lid. Also does well in the waterline and doesn't transfer. I use this everywhere from a...
COVERGIRL - Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner Pencil (in White Out)

1 review

So so SO disappointed by this eyeliner. Not only did it crumble when I tried to use it but it would not even line my eye properly. Maybe I got a broken one but at $9.00 this wasn't that cheap either! Covergirl, you can do better! (There was definitely nothing "perfect" about it...
Karl Lagerfeld Model Co Liquid Liner

1 review

This eyeliner has a angled felt-tip that allows for better control and precision when drawing/lining in the eyeline. First application is not super pigmented but can definitely build to a richer black. It is water resistant but not waterproof. Comes off easily with makeup wipe...
White eyeliner

1 review

I love this i have been wearing thethe same eye liner since middle school its always popped my eyes the way i like i dont really know how to use eye shaddow
The Body Shop Star Stamp Liner

1 review

I was impressed with this eyeliner/star stamp duo. Quality it’s great. The eyeliner slides super easily, very dark. The star stamp it is so cute. Price was awesome as I just paid $5 (sale) I am gonna go back to buy more.
Maybelline x Gigi Hadid East Coast Collection Liquid Eyeliner

1 review

The eyeliner is super easy to use for folks that haven't mastered the winged technique as the tip is a foam pointer rather than the brush that some eyeliners come in, so you can rely on the pointer to draw out nice lines. I bought the eyeliner in black and the color was...