Eyeliner Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
481-500 of 906

e.l.f. Cosmetics Studio cream eyeliner

3 reviews

This is hands down the best gel eyeliner I have ever used in my life, including high end ones too! It is so creamy and so easy to work with. It does not dry out like other gel eyeliners I have used. It is jet black and looks amazing. Also, it is soooo inexpensive! They also come...
Model Co Eye Define Eye Pencil

1 review

I really like this pencil. Normally I find pencils break SO easily and then don't sharpen properly - ever. This pencil has a nice tip, and goes on pretty smoothly to create a nice accent for my mascara. The sharpener as the lid is an ingenious idea! I'll never lose my...
MAC Cosmetics Fluidline in Blacktrack

26 reviews

This is one of my everyday essentials in my makeup bag, I like a black smokey eye look and a defined eyeliner which does not irritate or smudge, this does just that, I love it on my eye, you can make the line as thin or as thick as you want.
Rimmel London Scandal'Eyes Gel Eyeliner

3 reviews

A great reasonably priced product. This eyeliner glides on smoothly and is easily sharpened to the width you want. My go to colour is the black - it is perfect both for everyday and dressing up at night. Conveniently available at your local pharmacy or department store
ML felt tip eyeliner in Emerald Isle

1 review

I am a fan of simple, fun makeup looks for everyday. I was excited to try this shade because I find that greens and blues make my eyes really pop. This liner has a gentle felt tip that makes the product easy to apply. I found that the felt tip drys easily though. Nice color when...
L'Oreal Paris Infallible Never Fail Silkissime Eye Pencil

8 reviews

I have tried it in Green Ivy, Gold, Teal and Cobalt Blue (teal and cobalt blue may have slightly different names). All are very good, glide on with ease and stay. I also seal it with a product from Yves Rocher (Top Coat for Eye Make-Up Fixing, Glossy effect), and they work...
Ardene Eye Pen - Black

1 review

I was skeptical about this eyeliner, but it turned out to be quite good. It is a chunkier eyeliner pencil, so I mostly use it for bolder looks, or smudging. It wipes away quite easily, which is a blessing for smudging but a curse for long wear, so it depends what you are using...
NYX Cosmetics Eye Liner in Golden Bronze

3 reviews

Great quality for great price very nice packeging color so gorgeous apply really easily and get shape to uour eyes very happy with my purchase recommend this product
TheBalm Mr.Write(now)

2 reviews

TheBalm cosmetics are responsible for my favourite cosmetic, so I was so excited to try their take on eyeliner. I was a bit disappointed as I expected the color to be more gold, but it's actually a lot more bronze on the skin and can look muddy once other makeup is applied. I...
LINE EXPRESS® EYELINER

1 review

This is by far the best eyeliner I have tried in my lifetime! Glides smoothly to give you a very precise eyeline. The smoothing end does a good job at smudging the line for a subtle effect.
Max Factor Masterpiece High Precision Liquid Eyeliner

1 review

So I got this product for free to test out. I am by no means great at putting on eyeliner, it fact my skills are kinda below average so I was excited when I saw that this eyeliner claims to make application easier.Unfortunately I found that the paddle applicator makes it harder...
Revlon Colorstay Liquid Liner Pen

1 review

Does exactly what it claims. Defined lines and no mess. Stays until you take it off.
Physicians Formula Eye Definer Felt-Tip Eye Marker

6 reviews

I got mine in "Warm Black" rather than "Ultra Black" and it wasn't a good choice. It looks like a watered down version of a normal black eyeliner. Brush dried up rather quickly as well.
Mary Kay Eyeliner ~Black

1 review

This product is great! The best eyeliner I have tried!! I try new eyeliner's and always go back to the Mary Kay kind!
The body shop smoky eye definer

1 review

Great eye liner for a smoky eye, the smugger let's you create the effect that you would like . The eye liner applies nicely and stay's on quite nicely but it does make my eyes itchy and watery.
Annabelle Cosmetics Eyeink Liquid Eye Liner

17 reviews

I decided to spend a bit more money on this product and was extremely disappointed. Streaky, No "ink" in this eyeink. The thin side was dried out, and any product that comes out is wrecked by the brush tips. The thick side is TOO big :( The maybeline liquid waterproof eyeliner...
e.l.f. Cosmetics glitter liquid liner in copper

1 review

Seriously cost like a dollar, this liquid lin error is gorgeous. I wore it all over my lids once and it was beyond beautiful. You seriously can't go wrong with it.
e.l.f Liquid Eyeliner

5 reviews

I am totally in love with this eyeliner! Though it is a small bottle, it is so creamy and is applied so easily. I use it pretty much daily, since it is one eyeliner which doesn't leak or smudge. And the price is just as good as the product, you can pick it up for only $3.00! (I...
teeze Easy on the Eyes eyeliner

1 review

The pros... precision tip intense black smudge proof felt tip easy to use cons ... none!
MAC Cosmetics Feline Kohl Power Eyeliner

3 reviews

This is literally one of the best eyeliners I own. I buy two at a time. Even in comparison to my other more expensive brands like Bobby Brown, I prefer the way this goes on so easily and stays a long time. It does not irritate and is very smooth. Two Downfalls are that cause of...