Eyeliner Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
561-580 of 906

L.A. Colors Jumbo Eye Pencil

1 review

Works great as a base for eyeshadow, but I strongly suggest using a primer, and maybe even a translucent powder before putting on eyeshadow over it. I use so many different shadows, brushes, and techniques when applying my eye makeup, it's really no big deal to add this extra...
maybelline color show eyeliner

1 review

This is a great eyeliner! I bought it in 420 Barely Beige to use under my eyes to brighten them, but I've found myself using it on my eyelids because of how smooth and creamy it is! The price makes this an even better deal; it also seems like it will last a long time. If you add...
Wet n Wild Eyeliner and Eyebrow Pencil

23 reviews

Why pay more than you have to?! I use this eyeliner to lightly fill in my eyebrows. I usually buy it at Dollarama and have never found a reason to spend more. I sharpen it to make it precise - but I usually use it dull to smudge in my sparse eyebrow areas.
NYC kohl eyeliner in the navy

1 review

This is worst eye pencil. It was so dry I couldn't even get it on my eyelid to out line my eye. I had to really apply it with press which hurt. Cheap, cheap, cheap! It would make for a better pencil crayon.
Geisha Ink Eyeliner

4 reviews

I like this eyeliner because it is very easy to apply and you get a pretty neat and precise line. I find that it does not stay on as long as it is supposed to but it does the job. It is however a little on the expensive side.
CoverGirl Ink It Eye Liner

13 reviews

This is the first time I've tried Covergirl's Inkit line. I used the cocoa ink shade and think its my new favorite eyeliner, it stays on really well. My eyes water a lot at the corners and its stayed on and didn't smear. I haven't tried it on the waterline or tightlining so...
Annabelle Cosmetics kohl eyeliner in 116 White

1 review

This Annabelle 116 white eyeliner is pretty amazing it goes on smooth and I don't have to go over my water line a bunch of times just to make it show up white and it also stays in place for quite awhile
CoverGirl Ink It! Liner in Black Ink

4 reviews

Another great product! Gone are the days of using pencils that tug at your eyes. This eyeliner goes on smooth, keeps its colour and lasts all day; what more can you ask for!?! I use it daily and rarely need to re-apply. One eyeliner usually lasts me about 3 -4 months - it's...
L.A Colors Grafix Eyeliner

1 review

So I don't see many postings about L.A. Colors which made me want to post about my experience with it. I have MANY products by L.A. colors and I love every single one of them. The Grafix liquid lner has the BEST brush/pencil I've ever used. Makes for a clean sweep every time...
Wet n wild kohl eyeliner white

1 review

Inexpensive, does the job, nothing to write home about. I wish it came in a more nuteral tone not such a bright white
L’Oréal Paris the Infallible Blackbuster

3 reviews

8yddihodyv9ryvc9eyc8teeg69g9e6h93owtgvieitejkivyauodafipsifsfshosfvsivsifvsigbsifbsirvsifsnirsvifslshigsifslgwiatbirallllllllllxkxjxnxnnxnxishwbsjzuwhjsuxhebfiurbekxjsbsjxjbsksjxmvzzkvvzkkfs
Maybelline Master Smoky Eyeliner

3 reviews

This product goes on smoothly, the smudge part I find isn't stiff enough but the eyeliner pencil part works great which is the good side of it. You get what you pay for with this product.
New York Color High Definition Eyeliner

1 review

I saw Tati on youtube recommending this and since she is a makeup professional, I had really high hopes for this eyeliner. Sadly, the pigmentation is very low, which is quite deceiving. I saw people here saying that you have to turn it upside down, which I did but it didn't...
Almay Eyeliner with Built In Sharpener

2 reviews

I love this eyeliner and keep purchasing it. It does do the job for me and I don't need to ever sharpen it or bother about making it sharper. Black is my favorite color to purchase.
Jesse's Girl Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

7 reviews

It works quite well but I wish it was a little bit matter. I didn't think it was very waterproof either, but that doesn't bother me!
Hikari Mechanical Eyeliner - Storm

2 reviews

I received this from ipsy and LOVE it. It's by far my favourite eyeliner. It's so pigmented and the tip is perfect for constructing a flawless winged look. Hardly smudges.
Bonne Bell EyeDefine Glow

1 review

(White eye liner) Great for many looks, I use it in my inner lower lash line for a more animated big eyed look. Doesn't last as long as I would like it to but I use a light layer of white eye shadow on top of it to seal and dry it in place.
Yves Rocher Creamy Kohl Eyeliner

2 reviews

i got this on sale and just wanted to try it! it is a nice soft pencil and gives a good rich color! love it!
L.A. colors grafix eyeliner

1 review

I have this eyeliner in purple and I love it! It gives me that pop I need to look a lot more awake. The formula is smooth and soft. The Brush looks like it would be a normal liquid eyeliner brush, but its not, its actually just plastic and I like it so the brush doesn't move...
JULEP Gel Eye Glider in Rich Brown

1 review

So, I am someone who uses a lot of eyeliner, I know what's good and what isn't. I can easily say that I LOVE these eyeliners! They don't smudge and stays perfectly on my eyes all day, this is a nice matte brown that is very versatile, you can even use them on your brows, I will...