Eyeliner Reviews

Sort by:  DateRating
701-720 of 906

Jordana 12 Hour Made To Last Liquid Eyeliner Pencil

1 review

The waterproof eyeliner that I usually get is backordered so I decided to try this inexpensive liquid eyeliner pencil from Jordana. How can you complain about a long-lasting eyeliner that costs less than $3? I’ve been using it for a couple of weeks and it was time to sharpen...
Maybelline Line Works Liquid Eyeliner

9 reviews

I find this eyeliner brush style easiest to apply. As long as you don't touch your eyes it won't come off for well over 24hours. I have woken up the second day looking pretty good (don't judge, I know I should remove my eye makeup at night). When it does come off with makeup...
COVERGIRL LashBlast Bombshell Intensity Liner

9 reviews

I feel in love..it make's fine lines without the struggle. It is super thin for the best lines. Good job covergirl. A must for everybody's make up kit
Revlon Luxurious Color Smoky Crayon in Black Smoke

1 review

This Smoky Crayon is great for smudging!
MAC Cosmetics Eye Kohl Eye Liner

17 reviews

This is a really great high-quality eyeliner that provides long lasting results. The only issue that I found is that it does smudge a bit but if that’s the look that you’re going for than this is great! Give it a try!
The Body Shop Eye Definer Shade Black

1 review

I received this eye liner as a gift. Good thing- I can't imagine paying money for this product. This eye liner was so hard it doesn't apply any color on my eyes. I tried sharpening it and then re-applying and it barely showed. It also hardly marks any color on my skin when I...
Manshiu Volume Glamour Eye Liner

1 review

This liquid eyeliner is pretty good, but the brush is just awful. If it had a smaller, finer brush, I'd be a lot happier. The liquid itself is great though.
Wet n wild fantasy makers glitter eyeliner

2 reviews

I have to agree that this was a awful product. Did not go on smooth and wore off super fast. Dont waste your money
Joe Fresh Gel Liner

2 reviews

The Joe Fresh Eye Liner is my goto eyeliner. It's non-smudge and inexpensive, with a super easy glide.
Rimmel London Scandal'Eyes Jumbo Liquid Liner

4 reviews

I decided to try the winged liner look and saw this. It looked like it would be a perfect starter liner to work with. It is easy to draw the line with thanks to the sturdy tip but it fades within a few hours. It's not quite as black as it's supposed to be and definitely isn't...
e.l.f. Cosmetics Black Eye Liner

3 reviews

This is for the black shimmer liner. For $1 USD it works fairly well. The eyeliner is a little on the hard side, but it still is pigmented when depositing color. I find that this works better on the lashline as opposed to the waterline. It doesn't smudge as easily as other...
Lord & Berry Eye liner

3 reviews

I received this in my February 2017 ipsy glambag. Pencil eyeliners are my go to liners. I prefer them over liquid because they are a lot easier to apply and I like that I can smudge them out for a simple smokey look. I have smaller eyes so I rarely every line my water line...
Pacifica Natural Waterproof Eye Pencil

2 reviews

I received this item in one of my Ipsy Glam Bags. I was not a fan of this eye-liner. I had a hard time applying it, I found that there was very little pigmentation, I apply it and it doesn't really look like there's anything on my eye. Even after sharpening it again I had...
Glo-minerals graphic liner

1 review

I am extremely disappointed with this product and surprised at the poor quality because I have liked almost all other Glo products I've used. I'm happy I didn't have to waste my money on this product and got it for free because I would have been that much more disappointed had I...
Maybelline-Eyestudio Master Drama Eyeliner

1 review

Midnight Master-smoothly shapes the eye!!!!!!
Maybelline new york line express (eyeliner) in pure white

1 review

This white eyeliner is perfect to put a little light on your eyes. The color is blendable and it really does the job. This is a must !
ARTDECO All in One Liquid Liner in Tropical Monsoon

1 review

The All In One Liquid Liner comes in 5 shades and has a brush tip applicator. Tropical Monsoon is a metallic green that could have been even brighter for me as I had to re-line my eyes over and over to get the colour impact I wanted. It was long-lasting as most liquid liners...
MAC Cosmetics Eye Kohl in Smolder

1 review

Pencil is too soft so it smears a lot and very quickly. Pretty much look like a hooker within the hour. Yuck.
Pur Minerals Eyeliner

3 reviews

i did not have any issues with make up until a couple of years ago when my lips started getting dry on the sides and when both my eyelids started getting itchy and peeling. the allergic reactions started very slow and has progressed through continuous use of the products which...
NYC High Definition Liquid Eyeliner

13 reviews

I was hoping for a pigmented dark rich liquid liner so I was a bit disappointed. It's a bit too sheer to my liking. It's also a bit too shiny when you do get an opaque color by going over your lines 2 or 3 times. The tip and the "pencil" itself is very nice and easy to...