The steak here is fantastic and the decor is very opulent. If you want to treat someone to an amazing steak then definitely consider coming here. I was here one New Year's Eve with some friends and we had a great time. A couple of critiques...

* Food is overpriced. It's good but you have to order everything a la carte. When you order a steak that is literally all you get.

* Service is not that good. The waiters we had on New Years didn't really seem to know what was going on (i.e the specials, who was serving our table, etc) but that may have just been holiday staff.

* Decor is very old school and a little stuffy. Hy's is old world romantic but I found it a little bit overkill. It's definitely an older crowd.

Regardless, the food was excellent and we had a really good time here.

If you want to take your man out for steak, this is the place to go!!! I took my man here for his birthday and it was a great experience. The atmosphere is absolutely romantic and elegant. The only thing I would complain about is that the lighting is really dim. But the most important thing is the steak - and the steak is pretty delish. If you like potatoes, get the twice baked potato on the side - you won't regret it!

I have to warn you though, this place attracts a bunch of rich jerks. I was pretty irritated with a few rich snooty customers that felt entitled to treat the servers like garbage. But if you can stand the stuffy Bay street atmosphere, then this would be a great place to go for steak.