I love this restaurant and can't believe I haven't already done a rating for it. My boyfriend took me to John's Italian Caffe for the first time probably about 3 years ago and we've been their many times since! I can tell you that the meats, pizza's, pasta's and salads are fantastic. I've tried something new every time I go. It's tucked into a street that you probably wouldn't go down unless you knew to go.

Unlike misschickie, I've never found noise to be a problem when I'm at John's and I've been at John's for both Lunch and Dinner on a few occasions. I guess that is something that is really luck of the draw, and I guess that I've gotten lucky that way. I do notice though that the building itself holds noise so, you find yourself talking much louder to talk over the people around you since it is a small space and everyones conversations get trapped in one little room.

I definitely highly recommend this place. The prices are reasonable and the food is fantastic!